Keto Vanilla Gelatin Squares

These keto vanilla gelatin squares are easy to make and a delicious change from boxed fruit flavored gelatin. Plus they are a low carb high protein snack that you can feel good about eating when on a low carb diet! And 4 jello squares have only 104 calories 0.8 grams of carbs and 8.8 grams of protein.

You might also like keto jello popsicles!

This is one of my first posts that I made many years ago and really need updating. The other day I was craving Jello but wasn’t in the mood for the typical fruit flavors and remember this post of keto vanilla gelatin squares.

My first recipe was for Creamy Chocolate Gelatin Squares because I love the chocolate flavor. However sometimes I like to eat these at night and the caffeine in the chocolate would disrupt my sleep. So I came up with a vanilla version to eat as a night time snack.

Also today I wanted to keep it simple with the vanilla flavored jello. It’s such a great healthy snack to have on hand when you want a sweet treat and even makes a good dessert. All you need is 5 simple ingredients and you can make these low carb high protein jello squares.

Recipe ingredients I used and substitutions.

The simple ingredients I used were almond milk, heavy cream, vanilla protein powder, Swerve sweetener and unflavored gelatin.

Almond Milk and Heavy Cream
You want to use unsweetened almond milk or any nondairy ilk as they usually have less carbs. Unsweetened coconut milk would be my second choice instead of almond. And you should heavy whipping cream or even coconut cream.

Vanilla Protein Powder
I really like IsoPure Vanilla Protein Powder. All of their protein powders are low in carb and taste good to me. You can use your favorite brand of choice. You can also use pea protein or things like that if you like but you will have to check the carb counts.

Great Lakes Grass-Fed Beef Gelatin Powder
Great Lakes Gelatin is a high quality gelatin from grass fed cows. However you can also use any kind unflavored gelatin powder like Knox that you can get at the grocery store. I just think Great Lakes is of good quality so I like to have it on hand.

Gelatin has a lot of protein and is beneficial for your skin, joints, nails, gut and more. Learn more about the health benefits from gelatin here.

Sweetener
I prefer Swerve products and use their confections powdered sweetener the most. You of course can use your favorite sugar substitute. And if you want even more vanilla flavor you can add a little vanilla extract. I would use ½ teaspoon of vanilla extract.

How to make vanilla protein gelatin.

Step 1: Get out a mixing bowl and add ½ cup of unsweetened almond milk. Sprinkle the gelatin over top and let sit for 5 minutes to let it bloom.

This step is similar to making regular Jello except we are using almond milk instead of cold water. 

Step 2: In a microwave bowl add the 1 cup almond milk, heavy cream, sweetener and water and microwave for 2 minutes until very hot. After the gelatin has sat for 5 minutes add this hot mixture and whisk so the heat dissolves the gelatin.

You can also do this step on the stove. Add everything to a small pan and heat to medium heat. Whisk everything together until just simmering then take it off the heat. 

This step is like regular yellow when you add the hot water instead we are using this creamy mixture.

Step 3: Add in the protein powder and whisk again until well combined. Pour the mixture into an square container or baking dish and refrigerate for a few hours until it has completely gelled.

Step 4: When done, take it out of the refrigerator and cut into squares. Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator. Please scroll down to view the printable recipe card.

Below you can see what this keto vanilla jello looks like when it’s done. Notice these are not transparent but have a white color to them. You could use food coloring if you wanted change them up. You can eat as much as you want. This is also a recipe you can play around with the flavoring or even add ins.

Ways to change up this recipe.

f you want to add some variety to this basic recipe you can switch up the flavors of the protein powder. You can also add different flavor extracts or sweet spices like cinnamon, pumpkin pie spice etc.

And lastly you can add additional ingredients like cocoa powder, sugar free chocolate chips, unsweetened coconut, fresh berries etc.

More high protein sweet keto snacks.

If you are looking to add more protein to your diet here are a few of my favorite high protein sweet snacks.

• keto peanut butter banana pudding
• keto coconut protein balls
• keto salted caramel protein ice cream
• low carb zucchini protein muffins
• keto banana bread granola with protein

And for a few more low carb gelatin recipes try this keto tiramisu recipe, jelly bean flavored jello cups, or this cinnamon or chocolate mocha panna cotta.

Well I hope you enjoy this quick and easy keto vanilla gelatin squares recipe. It’s really can come in handy sugar free recipe to have on hand when your sweet tooth is calling!

The nutritional information for 4 squares is 104 calories / 6.2g fat / 1.2g carbs / 0.4g fiber / 8.8g protein = 0.8g net carbs